CF Debate

Dual Experience Ambiguity

Overview

Because many types of conscious experience are possible, there cannot be a single CF algorithm. As a minimum there is one core algorithm that can integrate multiple contents, as minor variations of the whole algorithm that generate a given experience. As such, it is conceivable that adding one extra algorithmic step at the end would create a new experience. Taken as a new whole, we've now got two moments of experience that are distinct but overlapping in their use of source material (since each requires the full preceding algorithm to qualify). How does the algorithm know which boundary to draw? If it draws both, which one is you?

This dual experience or dual self ambiguity is worse where we imagine it taking place in terms of the same terminal step of the CF algorithm, depending whether the boundary is drawn to include one additional midway input or one additional prior step. This situation is more bizarre, because both distinct 'moments of experience' now come into place at the same time, on the same substrate, following the same algorithmic step. If we deleted the previous steps having completed them, there is nothing in the present that tells you about their distinct nature, but nonetheless there are two separate simultaneous and overlapping experiences due to their overlapping but slightly distinct past lightcones.

Responses

  1. Bite the bullet, perhaps even pointing to evidence in psychology of multiple selves presumed to overlap to some extent in the same brain substrate – tulpas, split personalities, internal family systems, etc.

    BUT: This route leads to epiphenomenalism, since we have no disciplined way to attribute causality over multiple systems sharing the same space.

  2. Prevent the possibility by fully specifying CF algorithms in which this issue does not occur.

    BUT: Need to define the CF algorithm in order to explore this possibility.

Further reading

  • No direct reference currently known. Ideas discussed at Ernst Mach Workshop in Prague (June 2025).